When someone is about to walk off a cliff, the sensible
thing to is to tell him or her even if it may offend. No one really likes
to face his or her foibles. So much of ourselves is invested in the way we
are, that change is a touchy thing. But embracing truth, warts and all, is
the first step towards real change.
Cutting my teeth in Operations, (not cheese, but Operations nonetheless),
and graduating from the school of hard knocks after 20-odd years in the
trenches, I have been privileged these last 11 years to share in the
intimate details of more than a handful of food-related businesses. This
has given me perspective, and the confidence to be blunt.
But I will speak first of Cars, not Cheese. Even a casual glimpse at how
the automotive industry fumbled its response to the so-called “Japanese
Invasion” can help us learn to better compete, if we read between the
How a handful of tiny companies, building engines by hand, in a country
devastated by losing a war could, in just a few decades, shake down giants
is a story worth telling in itself, but the inept, some say arrogant
refusal by US car manufacturers to face facts in spite of overwhelming
evidence is a cautionary tale we need to hear. In case you were on another
planet, last month Toyota overtook GM as the largest car company in the
Past decisions pave the road to present realities. While we are not to
blame, we are accountable for dealing with the consequences. So first,
a little history. In 1949 General Douglas MacArthur assigned an obscure
American statistician named W. Ed-wards Deming to help take a census of
Dr. Deming had dabbled in Management Theory but his ideas were
misunderstood back home. The Japanese were desperate, with nowhere to go
but up, so they in-vited Dr. Deming to speak.
In August of 1950 he met with top management from a variety of industries.
In attendance were what were to become the leaders of Sony, Toyota,
Panasonic, Mitsubishi, Honda and others, inspiring the change that led
from devastation to renewal, from ashes to producers of some of the finest
goods in the world. Toyota, in particular, seized on Dr. Deming’s ideas
and created a system of production that is the most efficient and
profitable in the automotive world.
What was kooky in the US, struck gold overseas. In fact, the very American
ideas espoused by Dr. Deming, an American, have met acceptance outside of
America in spite of resistance and misunderstanding at home. The root of
our refusal to listen to our own best minds comes from just after that War
US Industry grew incredibly from 1950 on, fueled not by better quality
products or more efficient production, but by a lack of competition. The
rest of the industrial world lay in ruins. We won not because we were
better but because we were the only choice. Profit was so easily made we
thought we knew what we were do-ing and stopped studying our competitors
or trying to improve.
In the 1970s, Henry Ford the younger said without shame on 60 Minutes that
Ford built cars poorly, and they would continue to do so until consumers
demanded better cars. They were making too much money with “planned
When the Japanese Invasion began, the automotive industry ridiculed them.
When they began to impact market share, the industry cried foul, rather
than own up to the fact that Japanese cars were cheaper, better built, got
better mileage, lasted longer and cost less to maintain.
So the auto industry went to Washington claiming subsidies, dumping, and
unfair business practices left them no choice but to beg for protection
and relief -anything but build a better car. They called customers who
bought Japanese un-American. Some Asians were actually beaten by
overzealous employees, though ironically, few if any were actually
What began in arrogance rooted in short-term thinking for short-term
profits, and was built on a foundation of thinly veiled contempt for
employees and consumers, fed by a lack of proper training, and led by an
overly robust management populated by men with little experience in the
job at hand, led to a bloated, unmanageable system that resisted change.
It would take another 15 years before the first US car company woke up
and hired Dr. Deming, leading to the creation of the Taurus, giving Ford
a brief run as the most profitable American Car Company. In the 90s, they
abandoned Deming’s way to ride the wave of the SUV, a change that has
led them to the brink of bankruptcy.
Our automotive industry seems to miss the essential at every opportunity:
mediocrity is neither patriotic, responsible, nor a ticket to long-term
For me, the glory in business is in providing real solutions and better
lives for those we serve. The rest is merely speculation. Only a system
built with humility rooted in long term thinking, founded on profound
respect for its people, processes, and machines in genuine service to its
customers framed by a lean management with hands-on experience and a
continuously trained workforce in whom pride of workmanship has been
allowed to flower can survive and profit in today’s fast moving,
Know-how and ability are patriotic, not wishful thinking or stubborn
adherence to a failed path. What previous generations used to call
“Savoir Faire” matters. In the words of Dr. Deming himself: “It is
not enough to do your best; you must know what to do, and then do your
This is the first in a series of columns discussing what can be done. We
will look at production systems, quality systems, management styles and
what is really needed to train a manager and other topics. It is this
author’s hope, like a drop of ink in a lake that eventually spreads to
every nook and cranny; these words will help ignite discussion. When
people discuss, good things happen. Until next time, consider the
Is your company more efficient, better motivated, and making a better
product than your worldwide competition? Do you deeply respect your
employees and their hidden potential? Do you invest regularly in educating
them and yourselves? Are you driven by the long or short term?
In the words of a Ford engineer years after they abandoned the Deming
philosophy: “Why isn’t quality second nature at Ford? Because cost is
king. For the past six or seven years, there’s been a huge emphasis on
cost reduction. You walk in in the morning and all the alligators are
circling.” Quoted in an article on Quality in the NY Times, June 13,
In case you think replacing a focus on cost reduction with a focus on
quality won’t work, let the facts speak for themselves:
Loss of Almost $2 Billion
Profit of 11 Billion, 681 million
Dan Strongin is managing partner and owner of Edible Solutions,
a consulting company focused on helping companies making great food
make a profit. He will be writing a monthly column in Cheese Reporter.
Strongin can be reached via phone at (510) 224-0493, or via e-mail at firstname.lastname@example.org
Strongin Articles written for Cheese Reporter
*Comments will remain anonymous.
Cheese Reporter retains the right to publish anonymous comments to
continue the discussion of this editorial. Comments do not necessary
reflect those of Cheese Reporter Publishing Co. Inc.